If you're reading this, you probably just Googled "sales commission Excel template" hoping to find a spreadsheet that would finally solve your commission tracking problems.
I've been there. I downloaded dozens of templates. I even built my own. And after years of spreadsheet hell, I can tell you exactly why they all eventually fail—and what actually works instead.
The Template Trap
Commission templates seem perfect at first. Someone already did the hard work of setting up the formulas. You just plug in your numbers and watch the magic happen.
Except here's what actually happens:
- Month 1: Template works great. You feel like a genius for finding it.
- Month 2: You notice a calculation seems off. You dig into the formulas and make a "quick fix."
- Month 3: Your comp plan changes slightly. Now you need to update 15 cells.
- Quarter 2: The template is 50% your modifications. The original structure is gone.
- Year 2: The spreadsheet is unmaintainable. You start looking for a new template.
This cycle repeats forever because templates aren't built for your comp plan. They're built for a generic plan that doesn't exist in the real world.
The Tiered Commission Problem
The biggest issue with Excel templates is tiered commission. Most comp plans look something like this:
- First $375K: 6% commission
- $375K - $469K: 8% commission
- $469K - $562K: 10% commission
- Above $562K: 12% commission
Simple enough to understand. Nightmarish to calculate in Excel.
The problem: when you close a deal that pushes you from one tier to the next, you don't get the new rate on the entire deal. You get the old rate on the portion below the threshold and the new rate on the portion above.
Building this logic in Excel looks something like this:
That's for cumulative revenue. For individual deals where you need to track which portion of each deal falls into which tier, it gets exponentially worse.
The Real Danger
These formulas don't throw errors when they're wrong. They just give you a number that looks plausible. You won't know it's incorrect until your paycheck is short.
Other Template Failures
Contract Length Rates
Many companies pay different rates for 1-year vs 2-year contracts. Now your formula needs another dimension. Your neat spreadsheet becomes a maze of VLOOKUP and INDEX/MATCH functions.
Quarter Rollover
Every quarter, you need to reset your cumulative totals but keep your deal history. Templates don't handle this automatically. You end up manually copying tabs, fixing references, and praying nothing breaks.
Mid-Year Plan Changes
When your company adjusts tier thresholds (which happens constantly), you need to update hardcoded values scattered throughout your formulas. Miss one, and your calculations are silently wrong.
Historical Analysis
Want to compare Q3 this year to Q3 last year? Good luck finding that data in your template that you've modified 47 times.
Why People Keep Using Them
Despite all these problems, templates persist because the alternatives seem worse:
- Trust your company's system: Many companies don't have one, or it's opaque and you can't verify the numbers.
- Enterprise software: CaptivateIQ and Spiff cost $30-50/user/month and require company buy-in.
- Do nothing: Just wait for your paycheck and hope it's right.
None of these options give you what you actually want: accurate commission tracking that you control without spending hours maintaining it.
What Actually Works
After years of template frustration, I built Comish specifically to solve these problems:
- Tiered math that works: Set your tiers once. The system handles all the boundary calculations automatically, including deals that span multiple tiers.
- Contract length support: Different rates for 1-year vs 2-year? It's a setting, not a formula modification.
- Automatic quarter tracking: Log deals by date, the system organizes them into quarters. No manual copying or reference fixing.
- Change your plan anytime: Update your tier thresholds in one place. All calculations update immediately.
- Export when needed: PDF reports and CSV downloads for taxes or verifying your employer's numbers.
The $5 Question
Is your time worth more than $5/month? If you spend even 30 minutes per month maintaining a spreadsheet (and you probably spend more), Comish pays for itself immediately.
When Excel Still Makes Sense
To be fair, templates work fine if:
- You have a simple flat-rate commission (no tiers)
- Your comp plan never changes
- You close fewer than 5 deals per quarter
- You genuinely enjoy building and debugging formulas
But if you have tiered commission, contract multipliers, or a plan that changes at least once a year? You're fighting a losing battle with spreadsheets.
The Bottom Line
Excel templates for commission tracking are like building your own furniture. Possible? Yes. A good use of your time? Usually not.
I spent years maintaining increasingly complex spreadsheets. I caught errors after they cost me money. I wasted hours on formula debugging that could have been spent selling.
That's why I built Comish. Not because spreadsheets can't work, but because they shouldn't require a part-time job to maintain.
Done with Spreadsheets?
Try Comish free for 14 days. Set up your comp plan in 5 minutes. Never debug a commission formula again.
Start Free Trial